Default constructors

Consider the following code:

class Animal {
    protected $what = "nothing";
    function sound() {
        echo get_class($this)." says {$this->what}"; 

class Cow extends Animal {
    protected $what = "moo";
    protected $owner;
    public function __construct($owner) {
        $this->owner = $owner;
        // parent::__construct(); (?)

$a = new Cow("Old McDonald");

This code represents a simple class hierarchy. Now let us consider the line marked by (?). Of course we can not call the parent ctor there since we do not have one. But let’s say we refactored the base class and added the parent ctor which does some stuff:

class Animal {
   protected $born;
   public function __construct() {
      $this->born = time();

Seemingly, we didn’t do anything wrong here, right? But now our code is broken, since Cow::__construct does not call Animal::__construct. So we should go to every class extending Animal and fix them. The problem here we could not avoid this problem – unless we stick empty ctor into Animal when it doesn’t need it, we can not call it from Animal’s child classes. Sticking empty ctor into every class in case we’d ever want to extend it does not sound like a nice idea. Not being able to add a default ctor (i.e. one not needing any parameters) to a base class is also not good.

So what if we make default ctor always exist? If it’s not defined, calling parent::__construct() would just do exactly nothing. But if we ever implement it, all the child classes will be ready.

In fact, in Java for example it is mandatory to call the parent ctor, and if the class has none the default one is supplied by the language.
PHP does not enforce it, but it is very rarely a good idea not to. Right now, PHP does not allow to do the right thing here, but it should.